Pappone Method - My Test Thread
Last Post 11-04-2007 5:40 AM bywashingtond. 15 Replies.
    Printer Friendly
    •  
    •  
    •  
    •  
    •  
    Sort:
    PrevPrev NextNext
    You are not authorized to post a reply.
    AuthorMessages
    ChuKronosUser is Offline
    New Member
    New Member
    Send Private Message
    Posts:26
    Member Since: 03-11-2007 7:26 AM
    ChuKronos

    --
    03-11-2007 8:48 AM
      So, I have slowly been switching my tank to SPS corals. After seeing some results of others trying the Pappone method, I decided I would give it a try. I am going to post pics of each SPS coral as I dose to show the growth, or lack thereof, in my system. I am running T5's over my tank. It is a 6 light, 48" Tek. My lights are set up s follows:

      (front to back)
      ATI - Blue+
      ATI - AquaBlue
      GE - 6500K
      ATI - Blue+
      ATI - AquaBlue
      ATI - Blue+

      I dose kalk in my auto topoff. I use 1 teaspoon per gallon of water. My topoff is only 2 gallons. I do that so the Kalk doesn't lose effectiveness. I have to refill it every 1.5 days. I could add topoff myself, but the auto topoff keeps the water levels the same.

      I also use phosphate remover via a TwoFishies Reactor. It is running at 30-35g an hour. My sump hold about 15 gallons. It has a 5-6 gallon skimmer area, a 4-5g refugium with chaeto, and a 4-5g return area. I use a quiet one return pump. It is rated at about 400g/h at mt tanks return height. I also have a sealife systems skimmer. I will be replacing that in the coming months. For additional flow, I have 3 Koralia #4's in my tank. I add 15 drops of strontium every other day. I also add .5 capful of Iodine every other day. Calcium is added at a capful per day. I am going to be switching to Randy's Two Part soon.

      Nothing will be switched out on my system until after the first 6 weeks. That way, there will be no blaming anything on something new being added. i.e., new skimmer, or two part dosing.

      I will post pics in my next post. 

      -Chuck
      Steve AllenUser is Offline
      ReefChat Staff
      Basic Member
      Basic Member
      Send Private Message
      Posts:334
      Member Since: 02-17-2007 3:19 PM
      Steve Allen

      --
      03-11-2007 8:52 AM
      Cool! Going to follow along with great interest. I have been considering the Pappone food myself, just not sure about it. I may start another thread like this for Prodibio as I am considering dosing that again.
      Jeremy WolffUser is Offline
      ReefChat Staff
      Basic Member
      Basic Member
      Send Private Message
      Posts:111
      Member Since: 02-17-2007 3:27 PM
      Jeremy Wolff

      --
      03-11-2007 8:53 AM
      Sounds like a plan Keep us posted.
      real time stats
      Click my image for a graphed history.


      Come Chat with Us!
      Glenn FarmerUser is Offline
      ReefChat Staff
      Basic Member
      Basic Member
      Send Private Message
      Posts:135
      Member Since: 02-17-2007 4:00 PM
      Glenn Farmer

      --
      03-11-2007 1:04 PM
      Tagging along to see the progress
      Tom FortUser is Offline
      ReefChat Staff
      Basic Member
      Basic Member
      Send Private Message
      Posts:116
      Member Since: 02-17-2007 5:46 PM
      Tom Fort

      --
      03-15-2007 3:53 AM
      Waiting for that "next post" with pictures.
      May you all be well and happy.

      210 mixed reef with 90 gallon sump/fuge
      22 gallon frag tank
      20 gallon Mantis tank
      SpsFreakUser is Offline
      New Member
      New Member
      Send Private Message
      Posts:22
      Member Since: 03-16-2007 12:59 PM
      SpsFreak

      --
      03-17-2007 7:27 PM

      Im gonna follow this too.  I am really interested in trying out either the zeovit or pappone method.  I'm kind of leaning towards the pappone b/c the zeovit seems like a HUGE amount of money.  Are you following the BC pappone method?  Dosing AAs and keeping alk and calcium at higher than NSW levels? 

      ChuKronosUser is Offline
      New Member
      New Member
      Send Private Message
      Posts:26
      Member Since: 03-11-2007 7:26 AM
      ChuKronos

      --
      03-22-2007 12:58 PM
      Sorry about being lazy and not posting pics. I'll try and get them up this weekend.
      -Chuck
      ChuKronosUser is Offline
      New Member
      New Member
      Send Private Message
      Posts:26
      Member Since: 03-11-2007 7:26 AM
      ChuKronos

      --
      03-24-2007 5:29 AM

      Okay, here are my beginning pics:









      Not good of these 2:



      After next week, I will have completed 3 weeks. I will post new pics to show the progress. I see some progress so far, but not a ton. I will say, I can see a difference. Remember, I have had most of these frags since the November frag swap. Until I started this, there was barely any progress.

      -Chuck

      (edited by 5y5tem 0verload @ 9:35am on 3/24/07 - linked the urls to the images)

      ChuKronosUser is Offline
      New Member
      New Member
      Send Private Message
      Posts:26
      Member Since: 03-11-2007 7:26 AM
      ChuKronos

      --
      03-24-2007 5:39 AM
      sorry about the poor quality pics. I hope the next set will be better.
      Jeremy WolffUser is Offline
      ReefChat Staff
      Basic Member
      Basic Member
      Send Private Message
      Posts:111
      Member Since: 02-17-2007 3:27 PM
      Jeremy Wolff

      --
      03-24-2007 5:40 AM
      I think they look good.. and the corals do as well.
      real time stats
      Click my image for a graphed history.


      Come Chat with Us!
      ChuKronosUser is Offline
      New Member
      New Member
      Send Private Message
      Posts:26
      Member Since: 03-11-2007 7:26 AM
      ChuKronos

      --
      04-06-2007 9:13 AM
      I haven't noticed huge growth. I think I am going to up the dosing and see what happens. I will post pics before I dose next Friday.
      -Chuck
      Jeremy WolffUser is Offline
      ReefChat Staff
      Basic Member
      Basic Member
      Send Private Message
      Posts:111
      Member Since: 02-17-2007 3:27 PM
      Jeremy Wolff

      --
      04-09-2007 6:58 AM
      Have you noticed any change in color since you started the feedings?
      real time stats
      Click my image for a graphed history.


      Come Chat with Us!
      Glenn FarmerUser is Offline
      ReefChat Staff
      Basic Member
      Basic Member
      Send Private Message
      Posts:135
      Member Since: 02-17-2007 4:00 PM
      Glenn Farmer

      --
      04-09-2007 12:32 PM
      Isn't it a pain to keep turning stuff on and off for feeding? Think I would forget to add the collection cup back on the slkimmer.
      ChuKronosUser is Offline
      New Member
      New Member
      Send Private Message
      Posts:26
      Member Since: 03-11-2007 7:26 AM
      ChuKronos

      --
      04-13-2007 8:13 AM
      Posted By 5y5tem 0verload on 04/09/2007 8:58 AM
      Have you noticed any change in color since you started the feedings?


      To be honest, I have not noticed a change in color. But, I don't think pappone was designed for color enhancement. They have grown somewhat, but not like crazy. When I am finished I will post pictures of the growth I had the previous 5 months and the growth during the last 6 months. In my system, growth has increased some. In others, it would probably be more dramatic.
      ChuKronosUser is Offline
      New Member
      New Member
      Send Private Message
      Posts:26
      Member Since: 03-11-2007 7:26 AM
      ChuKronos

      --
      04-13-2007 8:16 AM
      Posted By Glenn on 04/09/2007 2:32 PM
      Isn't it a pain to keep turning stuff on and off for feeding? Think I would forget to add the collection cup back on the slkimmer.


      This is the biggest PIA during the process. I have to pull my carbon, turn off the phosban reactor and turn down my skimmer. It isn't a lot of work, but I still don't like doing that. While my growth hasn't been what 99.9% of people would call, "impressive," I am happy with it so far. Especially since I had so little growth before.

      -Chuck
      DavidUser is Offline
      New Member
      New Member
      Send Private Message
      Posts:26
      Member Since: 11-04-2007 4:27 AM
      David

      --
      11-04-2007 5:40 AM
      Any updates? I have been using Pappone for several months and really could not tell any difference in color or growth. I did notice that the fish love the stuff as they come out to eat it even after the lights have been off for a half hour.
      David
      200 Gal SPS Reef Tank
      75 Gal LPS/Softie Reef Tank

      You are not authorized to post a reply.


      Active Forums 4.3

      Find Your Group

      No matter how you connect, you'll find your group - whether it's about Nanos or Large Reef Systems, Equipment or Livestock, you'll be able to find your group here.

      Find A Group

      Suggestions

      This is YOUR site, so if you have suggestions or feedback on how we can improve it for you, please let us know! We do our best to keep up!
       

       

      Make A Suggestion

      Get Started

      In just a few steps you'll be able to connect with other members, join and create groups, start a conversation and more.  It only takes a minute and is completely free to join.

      Join ReefChat

      Find Your Group

      No matter how you connect, you'll find your group - whether it's about Nanos or Large Reef Systems, Equipment or Livestock, you'll be able to find your group here.

      Find A Group

      Suggestions

      This is YOUR site, so if you have suggestions or feedback on how we can improve it for you, please let us know! We do our best to keep up!
       

       

      Make A Suggestion

      Get Started

      In just a few steps you'll be able to connect with other members, join and create groups, start a conversation and more.  It only takes a minute and is completely free to join.

      Join ReefChat

       

      Copyright 2010 by ReefChat.org - A reef keeping communityTerms Of UsePrivacy Statement
      belstaff jackethandbags ukprada handbagshandbags salemulberry handbags coach handbags belstaff jacketsbelstaff shop miu miu handbagshandbags on sale